A worked example

Riverside Housing Collective, from four willing friends to a working board year

Riverside is a fictional but ordinary case: a five year old housing nonprofit with a two million dollar budget, a founder who chairs her own board, and four members who were recruited because they said yes. Below is the whole path through Board Builder and Cadence Designer, ending with the full meeting plan for the year.

1

Composition matrix: score the board you actually have

Every current member scored 0, 1, or 2 on each competency. Nothing here is a judgment of character. It is a map of what the board can do in a room without outside help.

MemberFinanceLegalReal estateFundraisingProgramCommunityHRAdvocacy
Dana ReyesFounder, chair by default00112201
Marcus OllivierCollege friend of founder10001100
Priya SundaramFormer volunteer coordinator00012210
Ken AbaraNeighbor of founder01000101
Board total11125612

Finance scores 1 across four people. Legal scores 1. Real estate, for a housing developer, scores 1. Community and program are genuinely strong. Riverside does not need a bigger board. It needs three specific competencies it has never had.

2

Scorecards: evaluate three prospects honestly

Each prospect is rated one to five on engagement, time, capital access, independence, and mission fit. Independence is where most founder boards fail, so it is scored separately rather than folded into fit.

Alicia Nunez

Credit union commercial lender

  • Engagement
  • Time capacity
  • Capital access
  • Independence
  • Mission fit

Closes the finance gap outright and brings a lending network the organization has never had. Moderate time, so she is a committee chair rather than board chair. No prior relationship with the founder, which is exactly what this board needs.

Recruit for seat one

Theo Marsh

Affordable housing attorney

  • Engagement
  • Time capacity
  • Capital access
  • Independence
  • Mission fit

Legal and real estate in one seat, plus he has sat on two housing boards and knows what good governance looks like. He will hold the board to its own bylaws, which is uncomfortable and necessary.

Recruit for seat two

Grace Whitmore

Retired bank executive, longtime donor

  • Engagement
  • Time capacity
  • Capital access
  • Independence
  • Mission fit

Generous and available, but she has been a personal supporter of the founder for six years and has already said she does not want to disagree in public. Better as a fundraising committee member than a board seat right now.

Hold, offer committee role

Grace is the hardest call and the most common one. High availability, real generosity, and a six year friendship with the founder. She becomes a committee member, which keeps her contribution and protects the board's independence.

3

Nucleus plan: five seats, staged over eighteen months

  1. Seat 1: Finance and audit

    0 to 6 months

    Reads statements independently, chairs finance committee, signs off on the audit.

    Alicia Nunez, offer extended

  2. Seat 2: Legal and real estate

    0 to 6 months

    Reviews acquisitions and leases, keeps the board inside its bylaws.

    Theo Marsh, offer extended

  3. Seat 3: Fundraising and capital

    6 to 12 months

    Opens funder doors, models the one activity per cycle standard.

    Sourcing through the ecosystem map

  4. Seat 4: Resident and community voice

    12 to 18 months

    Lived experience of the housing the organization builds, elected by the tenant council.

    Tenant council nomination process opens in Q3

  5. Seat 5: Chair

    12 to 18 months

    Runs meetings so the founder can stop chairing the board that evaluates her.

    Elect from seated members once four are working well

4

Ecosystem map: who each seat should open a door to

RelationshipTypeWhy it mattersOwner
Metro Housing TrustFunderLargest local capital source, never appliedAlicia
City housing officeGatekeeperControls the parcel pipelineTheo
Riverside Tenant CouncilCommunityNominates the resident seatPriya
Northside CDCPeer orgHas run this playbook for a decadeDana
Regional bank CRA deskFunderBelow market construction debtAlicia
5

Expectations agreement: what every member signs

  • Attend four board meetings a year, two of them in person.
  • Serve on one committee and show up to its meetings.
  • Read the packet before the meeting, every time.
  • Complete one fundraising activity per quarter, defined broadly.
  • Make a personal gift that is meaningful to you, in the first ninety days.
  • Disclose conflicts in writing and recuse without being asked.
  • Give the executive director honest feedback once a year, in writing.

Signed before the first meeting, reviewed every year. The point is not enforcement. It is that nobody joins this board believing it is a name on a letterhead.


6

Cadence Designer: the committee structure

Four committees for a two million dollar budget. Each has an owner, a meeting rhythm tied to the board calendar, and work that would otherwise land on the executive director.

Finance and audit

Owner: Alicia Nunez

Monthly for the first year, then before each board meeting

Reviews statements, owns the audit, presents plain language financials to the board.

Fundraising

Owner: Seat 3 once filled, Dana in the interim

Quarterly, three weeks before the board meeting

Tracks one activity per member per cycle and runs the capital campaign case.

Governance

Owner: Theo Marsh

Twice a year

Owns recruitment against the matrix, the expectations agreement, and the annual review.

Executive

Owner: Chair

Two weeks before each board meeting

Sets the agenda and handles only what genuinely cannot wait for the full board.

7

The full meeting plan for the year

Four board meetings, second Thursday of the month, 6:00 to 8:00 pm. Every date on this page was generated backward from those four meetings: packets land fourteen days out, committees meet before the packet closes.

Q1 board meeting

Set the year and adopt the budget

Thursday, February 12

Packet sent
January 29
Committees meet
Finance meets January 22, Executive meets February 5
Consent agenda
November minutes, Q4 financials, Committee rosters
Decisions on the table
Adopt the 2027 operating budget. Approve the audit engagement letter

The one strategic question

Which two neighborhoods do we commit to, and what do we say no to?

Alicia walks new members through the financial statement format before the meeting.

Q2 board meeting

Pipeline and capital

Thursday, May 14

Packet sent
April 30
Committees meet
Fundraising meets April 23, Finance meets May 7
Consent agenda
February minutes, Q1 financials, Gift report
Decisions on the table
Authorize the Elm Street acquisition offer. Approve the capital campaign case

The one strategic question

If the Metro Housing Trust says yes, what breaks first in our operations?

Theo circulates the acquisition memo with the packet, not at the table.

Q3 board meeting

People and governance

Thursday, August 13

Packet sent
July 30
Committees meet
Executive meets July 23, Governance meets August 6
Consent agenda
May minutes, Q2 financials, Policy updates
Decisions on the table
Seat the resident board member. Adopt the executive director review process

The one strategic question

What does this board need to be able to do two years from now that it cannot do today?

Tenant council nomination closes July 15 so the candidate is in the packet.

Q4 board meeting

Performance and the year ahead

Thursday, November 12

Packet sent
October 29
Committees meet
Finance meets October 22, Fundraising meets November 5
Consent agenda
August minutes, Q3 financials, Committee reports
Decisions on the table
Elect the board chair. Approve the 2028 meeting calendar

The one strategic question

Where did the board add real value this year, and where were we ceremonial?

Quarterly review scores collected from every member two weeks out.

8

The prep countdown that repeats every quarter

  1. 28 days outExecutive committee drafts the agenda and names the one strategic question.
  2. 21 days outCommittee chairs submit written updates, one page each.
  3. 14 days outPacket goes out: consent agenda, financials, decision memos.
  4. 10 days outExecutive director confirms attendance and quorum.
  5. 7 days outChair calls two members to surface objections before the room.
  6. Meeting dayConsent in five minutes, decisions in thirty, strategic question in forty.
  7. 3 days afterMinutes, assignments, and owners circulated with due dates.
  8. 14 days afterChair checks in on any assignment that has not moved.

Riverside runs this eight step countdown four times a year. That is the whole discipline. The calendar never moves, and the content of each meeting changes with what the organization is facing.

Let's build yours.

Start with the composition matrix and score the board you have today. The gaps will be obvious within twenty minutes.